CoS Mid-Year Report: Our Top Ten
It’s hard to believe, but 2008 is halfway over. Time is a bitch, ain’t it? That being said, let’s jump to the point. We love top ten lists. Whether they’re self aggrandizing or pretentious, that’s for you to decide, but certainly, they help us clean house and keep some order around here. That’s why our staff writers have compiled some of their favorite albums this year (so far), all into a quaint, little top ten list.
How nice of us, huh?
While this year has been relatively dry so far, especially April, there have been some exceptional releases. Several artists stepped out of hibernation (R.E.M., The Magnetic Fields), some were brand spankin’ new (Vampire Weekend, Jukebox the Ghost), and some just continued on (The Raconteurs, NIN). Nevertheless, it was fun sorting through all the new ear candy that’s been made available and we can’t wait to see what else this year has in store for us.
10. Cut Copy - In Ghost Colours
Last month, staff writer Blaine Sayers proclaimed that this “refreshing and bright” album was littered with “catchy tunes that force you to tap your foot and nod your head”, where “each track is as good as the last.” If that isn’t a solid album, then you’re asking for way too much. These Australian rockers have been making some marks with their second album, and Sayers isn’t alone in his praise, with many reviews out of Pitchfork Media, Paste, and Drowned in Sound, all enjoying the electronic sounds. Be sure to keep an eye on this release, as it’s likely to be making the rounds of many top ten’s come December.
Check Out:
9. Stephen Malkmus & the Jicks - Real Emotional Trash
Earlier this year, I called Malkmus’ latest effort a “scattered, guitar rock driven album” and three or four months later, I still agree. Between “Cold Son” and “Dragonfly Pie”, the instrumentation shifts from simple to perverse in a matter of seconds, exemplifying the late Pavement frontman’s ability to rework the guitar with ease. Another one of our writers, Zarik Khan, had this to say of Real Emotional Trash, “Backed by musicians that read like a who’s who of indie rock, Malkmus combines the sounds of indie and experimental to achieve musical bliss.” There’s not much else there to argue.
Check Out:
8. Protest the Hero - Fortress
Another one of our writers, Jay Ziegler, called Protest the Hero “Canada’s next big thing” in his review of their latest album, Fortress. In fact, he was a bit overjoyed, to say the least, going so far as to label it, “the fourth column in a metal Parthenon of complex, yet awesome musical passages that guitarists will skin their fingers over for.” His opinions have yet to differ, as he digresses, “I think Protest the Hero honestly elevated guitar solos to a much higher level, and for a bunch of young kids, they could easily be Canada’s best metal band in recent years.” Does that sell you yet?
Check Out:
7. Foxboro Hot Tubs - Stop, Drop & Roll!!!
There’s something about a great surprise that comes off as both rewarding and memorable. With Foxboro Hot Tubs, the side project from our boys of Green Day, their sneaky online release was more than a surprise, it was a blessing. On the first couple of listens, I called their new sound “poppy, snap n’ beat rock n’ roll” and their debut “the most entertaining listen for it’s genre since Weezer’s 1994 debut.” While the former is just a simple observation, the latter is quite the statement, and something I still stand by today. It doesn’t seem like I’m alone either, as fellow writer Matt Melis explains, “This a record dripping of influences and full of songs you’d swear you have heard before, but somehow Foxboro makes it their own. It’s a refreshing throwback and one of the best modern alternative records I’ve heard in years.” Well, at least I’m not criminally insane.
Check Out:
6. The Black Keys - Attack & Release
The Ohio rock duo have a lot going for them. “Maturity” is one thing, according to our writer Laurie Fanelli, who insists their latest inherits an “intelligent simplicity in the sound, that allows the Black Keys talent to shine threw without being showy about it.” One of our other writers, E.N. May, tends to agree, but for other reasons, explaining, “The appeal for this gritty duo is that it is garage rock with strong roots in the old delta blues tradition. With Danger Mouse now on the record, the garage has opened just a little to let in some original growth.” Not too shabby for two boys from the Midwest. If they keep up this stride, Jack White might have to watch out for his back.
Check Out:
5. NIN - Ghosts I-IV
For Trent Reznor, 2008 has been his year. By closing out on a major label, he’s not only found freedom in writing what he wants, he’s free to release it in any way he pleases. The result? An overload of free, exclusive content that has been both superb and worthy of the NIN discography. The first of the online gifts was Ghosts I-IV, the sprawling 36 track instrumental album that will forever appease student filmmakers everywhere. While it’s a favorite among many of our staff members, writer Bill Fanelli, in his review, calls it “entirely new, refreshing and close to perfection.” He doesn’t seem to change his mind, either. “[Ghosts I-IV] still giv[es] us exactly what we want in a NIN album. Brilliant, innovative, liberating and most importantly…true!”
Check Out:
4. R.E.M. - Accelerate
There’s a word that’s rampant in R.E.M.’s latest record and one that describes anyone’s initial response to Accelerate. “Wow!” After 2004’s disappointing Around the Sun, it was more than a relief when the band came back in full force, rocking harder than musicians half their age today. In my review, I said that Accelerate “doesn’t try to make the band grow” and instead, “its more or less a throwback to the familial alternative feeling that started with 1987’s Document and peaked with 1991’s Out of Time.” Certainly the sound scales back some, but this album brings juice to a band that lost steam almost a decade previously. E.N. May seems to agree, “Accelerate proves that Michael Stipe and the band are back after a few less than notable records. The album has just enough growth to attract new listeners, and still sticks to what old time fans love best about the band.”
Check Out:
3. The Raconteurs - Consolers of the Lonely
Simply put, Jack White is insane. He’s an animal on stage, he duets and jams with everyone who’s anyone, and he looks like an enraged insomniac, which is probably true given his impressive discography and brilliant communication skills. Last Spring’s “left field” release of The Raconteurs sophomore album really shocked everyone. Not to mention, it brought some electricity to an otherwise stale season. Initially, I wasn’t too enthused with the second helping, insisting that it had “more flavor and less bite.” Looking back, and so soon, I regret not focusing on “Carolina Drama”, which might be the album’s real gem. Regardless of what I think, Consolers of the Lonely is a big staff favorite.
Check Out:
2. Hot Chip - Made in the Dark
No one can deny the irresistible electro-pop of Britain’s hottest indie act. It’s various sounds are not only inviting, but accessible to a variety of demographics (I tried saying that without being too “public official”-like). That being said, there’s reason we’re so giddy about it. Our own publisher, in his review, called Made in the Dark, “a pop masterpiece full of elegance, passion and lyrical quality.” He’s not alone. One of our readers, Nick Sprouse, commented, “This album is partly responsible for my renewed interest in modern music.” That’s generally a good thing, right?
Check Out:
1. Vampire Weekend - Vampire Weekend
Whatever Columbia University is teaching, they’re doing it right. Vampire Weekend is all the hype (or at least they were) and with good reason, they have a great sound and they know how to manipulate it to its full potential. Starting with “Mansard Roof”, continuing with “A-Punk”, and hitting an ethereal high with “Walcott”, it’s hard to dismiss this rising indie act. That’s the probably the reason I called their debut, “a stretch of mental nirvana.” Considering this is the top rated album of our staff, it’s not too hard of a statement to swallow, I guess. At least our publisher agrees, writing, “Though now known as much for its hype as it is for its sound, Vampire Weekend’s debut wlll stand the test of time thanks to a perfect balance of lyrical richness and musical tranquility.” Yeah, this album’s pretty hot.
Check Out:
The Breakdown:
Alex Young recommends: Jukebox the Ghost - Let Live and Let Ghosts, Vampire Weekend - Vampire Weekend, Hot Chip - Made in the Dark, Los Campesinos! - Hold on Now…Youngster, Sons and Daughters - This Gift
Michael Roffman recommends: Vampire Weekend – Vampire Weekend, R.E.M. – Accelerate, Foxboro Hot Tubs – Stop Drop & Roll!!!, Stephen Malkmus and the Jicks – Real Emotional Trash, NIN – The Slip
Jay Ziegler recommends: Protest The Hero – Fortress, Children of Bodom - Blooddrunk, The Magnetic Fields – Distortion, Alestorm - Captain Morgan’s Revenge, Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds - Dig!!! Lazarus! Dig!!!
Laurie Fanelli recommends: Hot Chip - Made in the Dark, Radiohead - In Rainbows (physical release), NIN - Ghosts I-IV, The Black Keys - Attack & Release, NIN - The Slip
Bill Fanelli recommends: Hot Chip – Made in the Dark, NIN – Ghosts I-IV, Moby – Last Night, NIN – The Slip, Junkie XL – Booming Back At You
Matt Melis recommends: Foxboro Hot Tubs - Stop Drop & Roll!!!, The Gutter Twins - Saturnalia
Matt Friedman recommends: Flogging Molly – Float, Thrice - The Alchemy Index, Vol III & IV, Atmosphere – When Life Gives You Lemons, You Paint That Shit Gold
Blaine Sayers recommends: Cut Copy - In Ghost Colours, The Last Shadow Puppets - The Age of the Understatement, MGMT - Oracular Spectacular, NIN - Ghosts I-IV, Vampire Weekend - Vampire Weekend
Zarik Khan recommends: Portishead - Third, Stephen Malkmus - Real Emotional Trash, Bon Iver - For Emma, Forever Ago, The Roots - Rising Down, Someone Still Loves You Boris Yeltsin - Pershing
E.N. May recommends: R.E.M. – Accelerate, The Black Keys - Attack & Release, Radiohead – In Rainbows, Fleet Foxes - Fleet Foxes
Phillip Roffman recommends: The Mars Volta – The Bedlam and Goliath, The Raconteurs – Consolers of the Lonely, The Helio Sequence – Keep Your Eyes Ahead, Protest The Hero – Fortress, Flight of the Conchords – Flight of the Conchords
Ashley Kjos recommends: The Raconteurs - Consolers of the Lonely, The Black Keys - Attack and Release, Elvis Costello - Momofuku, My Morning Jacket - Evil Urges
Nardo Marquez recommends: Santogold - Santogold, Man Man - Rabbit Habits, The Mars Volta - The Bedlam in Goliath, The Roots - Rising Down, Death Cab for Cutie - Narrow Stairs
Leo Paretti recommends: Vampire Weekend - Vampire Weekend, What Made Milwaukee Famous - What Doesn’t Kill Us, The Raconteurs - Consolers of the Lonely, R.E.M – Accelerate, The Black Crowes – Warpaint
See you around December.













Did spin really say korn was better than Pink Floyd??? I like spin and all thier interviews are great but sometimes they make some of the most over the top statements lol.
I’m just saying is rare for a pop artist to be acknowledged in top album’s list. Also if Burial and James Murphy (who makes all the sounds first and then has a live band play them I believe) what are they then? Electronica artists… just because its not hip hop orientated doesnt mean there not DJs.
Neither LCD Soundsystem or Burial are DJ’s. And since when does making money have anything to do with being an artist or not.
I mis-read your first post. I thouht you were validating your argument thru them. But anyway I have a hard time seeing people put Tha Carter 3 on any top ten due to its over commercialization. Especially pitchfork as they tend to ignore anything that went platinum for thier lists. (See top albums of 90’s list and wonder were is the grunge). Girl talk won’t be considered sadly not because hes a DJ (as most lists had Burial’s Untrue as either the best album or second to another DJ based LCD Soundsytem) but because hes a mashup artist. I just have a feeling that the prude people at pitchfork and rolling stone would put a person who samples other artists.
And you really need to listen to other hip-hop albums. I liked tha carter 3 but as a guilty pleasure thing. Lil’ Wayne isnt here as an artist he’s here to make money. Hes probably, the best at it but there are definetly better Hip hop albums that have been released. Try Blu & Exile’s Below The Heavens (For you lyrical) or Cool Kids Bake Sale (for your old school) or Wale’s mixtape about nothing (For the best of every aspect of Hip hop.)
Vampire Weekend certainly belongs on any list that includes The Strokes. I find it hilarious that anyone would consider either of those bands anything more than enjoyable commercial garbage, but whatever. At least it’s enjoyable. Everyone needs something to get nostalgic about at the high school reunion. And it is indeed a sad thing when what you call “commercial garbage” is better than an entire new wave of indie pop. Also, you say mash up like that alone makes Feed The Animals inherently worse than any of these albums listed. We are way past the point when anybody seriously has to defend DJs as musicians and I will take an excellent mash up over mediocre anything every time.
I think it is a mistake to view Pitchfork as an authority on musical quality. I personally only read Pitchfork when I am feeling masochistic (And Spin is way better for that, and also for some reason still delivered to my house even though I have never paid for it or asked for it, ever). And while we are discussing completely arbitrary rating scales, Pitchfork gave your precious Vampire Weekend basically the same rating as The Carter 3, so what does that mean? For what it’s worth, pound for pound I get more useful information from this site than I ever have from that one.
I don’t care what you listen to on your Ipod. I know from looking at this page every day at work for the past year that you guys don’t listen to hip hop besides Eminem and that you really like all these hipster bands, which is cool. Not everyone likes the same shit. I have lots of friends just like you. I call them out whenever they take themselves too seriously also. Spin once said that Korn was better than Pink Floyd? How do you think they feel about Korn now? Probably the same way you will feel about Titus Andronicus eventually. Titus Andronicus, who btw, have a worse rated album than Lil Wayne. In the end, making meaningless lists of stuff you like is a lot of fun. Musical taste is entirely subjective and I am just trying to keep you honest.
Vampire Weekend is considered one of the top 4 albums of the decade(behind Kid A, Is This It, and something else i dont remeber, by pitchfork. And Titus is definetly up there seeing as they gave it a 9.5 or something like that. So far this is the album that represents this whole new wave of indie pop bands. The Carter three is commercial garbage (albiet enjoyable) and Feed The Animals is a mash-up CD so as far as placing it up on top album lists its hard to give it the credit that it should.
Thinking long and hard and deep, in ten years will people be listening to Titus Andronicus or Vampire Weekend or the weak Sigur Ros albums? 5 years from now, I doubt any of us will remember how to spell Racontuers properly. If this is a good year for music, then every year has always been a good year for music. 2002, now THAT was a good year for music. You would be crazy to include a single album discussed on this page so far on a best of decade list. I doubt any of these albums could even beat anything from last years top 10. Even the top ten according to Pitchfork or Rolling Stone.
There is no accounting for taste, obvs, but I can only think of two “Albums” that will come with me intact out of this year so far, Feed the Animals and The Carter 3, which seemingly wins me no fans around here. There is a lot of year left to go, but I doubt I will be able to stretch that to 5 before January.
It’s a chicken or the egg, but there is a reason live shows are as important as they are right now.
Crap I completely forgot about TV on the Radio. Put that 2 or three. Never heard of Neon Neon. What does it sound like?
Luke, I agree. Vampire Weekend is still in heavy rotation with me. However, I think the year’s best now is between VW, The Hold Steady, Neon Neon, or TV on the Radio.
Wow it’s wierd to look back at this thing. The top 6 wouldnt even be considered now. This year has had some great releases.
1. Vampire Weekend by far and away still
2. Titus Andronicus
3. Crystal Castles
4. Fleet Foxes
5.Fucked Up
6. Hot Chip
7. The Racontuers
8. Los Campesinos!
9. Portishead
10. The Verve.
With releases still to come by the likes of The Cure, Kayne, and Los Campesnos! this year has been a damn good year for music.
I felt the same if Vampire Weeend was a summer release. Summer or spring really.
Third is great, really great, and definitely in my top 10. This might sound odd, but I feel if it were a Fall release, I would have enjoyed it more. It’s music for that season, at least for me it is.
Evil Urges was the name of that My Morning Jacket CD.
In no way is Vampire Weekend garbage. I agree that it is AOTY so far. My top ten would look like this off th top of my head.
1. Vampire Weekend- Vampire Weekend
2. Titus Andronicus- The Airing of Grievances
3. Portishead- Thid
4. The Raconteurs- Consolers Of The Lonely
5. Los Campesinos! Hold On Now Youngster
6. Sigur Ros- Not even going to try and spell it.
7. REM- Accelerate
8. My Morning Jacket-
9. Sleepercar- West Texas
10.The Black Keys - Attack & Release
Dan, I’ll agree that Titus is pulling, but how the hell is Vampire Weekend garbage? I’m lost there.
Luke,
I’ with you about Los Campesinos! And Titus Andronicus is starting to grow on me.
The Raconteurs and The Black Keys are the albums on your list worth mentioning, and some of them are pretty garbage (ahem, Vampire Weekend). The Airing of Grievances is AOTY so far.
Well, it’s all collated by staff selections. I’d agree with Portishead, at least to be in the top ten, but not sure about Los Campesinos! or Titus. Anyhow, thanks for posting!
It missing some definitly amazing albums. Titus Anddronicus and Portihead. Los Campisnos! deserves a spot as well. And I listened to the Protest The Hero CD. Not my stle but to be put in the same breath as Relationship of Command is completly bullshit. Sorry for the spelling errors btw.
Tha Carter III was overhyped, since “Tha Block Is Hot” there has been nothing worth listening to from Lil’ Wayne, and I will debate that till I’m blue in the face. All your typical mainstream garbage peppered with a little bit of “weirdo rap” a la Biz Markie and Kool Keith.
I am guessing that you all made your lists before The Carter 3 was leaked?
Well we must have had a different release date in Canada, YO!
Oh and Blaine Sayers: i’ll let it slide this time but that MGMT album came out last year, YO!
bobbyrisigliano reccomends: Atmosphere - When Life Gives You Lemons, You Paint That Shit Gold, The Black Keys - Attack & Release, Jain Vain and the Dark Matter - Love Is Where The Smoke Is, Nada Surf - Lucky, No Age - Nouns
Dec 17th, 2008 at 9:04 am
[...] there are some major deviations that you might not have expected (especially in comparison to our Mid-Year Report), but that’s what gives it character, right? [...]
Jun 27th, 2008 at 6:04 pm
[...] song tends to stick in the ol’ noggin for awhile after. Oh, by the way, did we mention we really like their [...]