I say “should” because 1,2,3 produce some fairly accessible indie rock, especially for a band so new to the market. There are hints of that Girls-like ’60s revival, indistinct gestures of surf rock, and touches of grainy, lo-fi acoustics that exist with any of your favorite DIY bands. Snyder’s lyrics are more or less about relationships and breakups, more or less the norm in indie rock these days.
What makes New Heaven work out so well is that the main factor perpetuated by Snyder and Co. is subtlety. There’s subtlety in Snyder’s high-pitched vocals, in the variation of guitar riffs present (see “Just Like Heaven”), in the vague involvement of electronic reverberation (see “Riding Coach”), and in the overall slow-building mechanisms that the band seems to favor throughout the entire LP. 1,2,3 don’t sway too far away from what they’re doing, and it’s blatant that they see themselves in a certain light, creating music in a certain way.
By maintaining this aesthetic on New Heaven, 1,2,3 project a kind of assertiveness, one that speaks volumes for the potential they have in creating more records down the road. Indie kids like albums that involve fluidity and consistency (think Beirut, Bon Iver, Fleet Foxes, and Grizzly Bear), and 1,2,3 throw that down in spades on New Heaven. It may not be a game changer (or comparable to the aforementioned bands), but it does showcase a shitload of flair and aptitude for producing indie rock.