Album Reviews

Carolina Chocolate Drops – Leaving Eden

on March 05, 2012, 7:57am
carolina-chocolate-drops-leaving-eden C+
Release Date

It’s not often that the instrument you can’t quite identify on a particular track turns out to be the five-string gourd banjo, but that’s the rhythmic, eclectic world of Carolina Chocolate Drops. The award-winning string band folksters bring a quick step and a soulful effort to their third full-length, Leaving Eden.

This is traditional music, sure, but it’s anything but stuffy. The first two tracks give a nice cross-section of the album’s tone. Fast-paced opener “Riro’s House” lights right into a kicky fiddle that zings straight on through the closing notes. Following that, “Kerr’s Negro Jig” features that bare gourd banjo and a captivating instrumental melody, haunting in its simplicity.

The album careens back and forth between slow and fast, wisely chasing anything depressing with another dose of that burning fiddle, a shot of whiskey after a good long cry. There are a few long, slow moments worth attention, including chilling closer “Pretty Bird”, featuring vocalist Rhiannon Giddens’ bottomless alto all alone, the better to showcase her commanding talent. She lends a throaty, infectious jazz to “No Man’s Mama”, a roaring celebration of freedom sung in full-on nightclub style.

A few moments, though, do disappoint; original composition “Country Girl” is unnecessarily preachy (lyrics include, “ain’t nothing like living in the South/ I want to shut your mouth”), and a few of the more old-timey numbers land just the other side of twee. But the Drops sound best when they’re having fun, and there’s no shortage of backyard dance party on this album. “Read ‘Em John” is a good ol’ fashioned call-and-response floor stomper, and jaunty “Run Mountain” will burrow into your brain and stick there. “West End Blues” is a sexy, slinky number on fiddle and banjo tinted with Giddens’ warm vocals.

Like the eponymous candy, Leaving Eden will draw you back for more of that sweet warmth to melt on your tongue. The Drops are the perfect antidote to the end of winter.

Essential Tracks: “No Man’s Mama”, “West End Blues”, and “Read ‘Em John”

1 comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

June 12, 2012 at 9:53 am

A lyric correction — it’s “Oh honey, shut your mouth”, an injunction that many of us raised in the South are quite familiar with.

Edited to add: The difference is actually pretty important. The context here isn’t “shut up”, it’s “don’t look so surprised”. (The idea being that the person is standing there with their jaw dropped.) The reason it matters is that the song describes the quintessential Southern rural experience, one which is usually mentally associated specifically with white people. This is a woman of color saying, “That’s actually my life experience too. Don’t look so surprised.”

It seems to me like that’s at the heart of the song. The stereotypes are that black people live in cities, and farmers are white. That disappears a lot of people. This song is about one of them making herself visible.


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 2,846 other followers