Today, A.V. Club shared another entry in its ongoing Undercover series, in which 25 bands cover 25 songs from a list of reader-submited suggestions. This time around, however, Screaming Females stopped by to perform their own cover, one that wasn’t exactly on the list: Sheryl Crow’s “If It Makes You Happy”. “I think Sheryl Crow is the only band that we can all agree on,” Marissa Paternoster confessed with a smirk. “That’s not true.” The band strikes hard into the late ’90s anthem and Paternoster’s vocals on the chorus slap some grime on what was already Crow’s grimiest song. Check it out below.