Album ReviewsHot

Phoenix – Bankrupt!

on April 22, 2013, 12:03am
Phoenix Bankrupt! C+
Release Date
Label
Formats

With just under a minute remaining on “Entertainment”, the first track and lead single off Phoenix’s latest album Bankrupt!, we arrive at the bridge. The bridge consists of one long syllable, “ohhh”, set loose above synthesizers and a metronomic bass beat. Given the track’s structure and golden Hollywood pop gloss feel, this moment should absolutely be the big and catchy shout-along climax to an already big and catchy single – and for a second, it sounds like it will be. But then it starts to drunkenly amble up and down on an arbitrary rhythm, hitting no less than 50 notes inside 20 seconds and rendering itself less a shout-along and more a chance for frontman Thomas Mars and his bandmates to share a private chuckle from the stage at fans who will surely botch it at shows. It’s a rude fake-out — the kind of fake-out Phoenix doubles down on throughout their fifth studio album.

Mars has been forthcoming about his departure from feeding the dopamine receptors of his fans: “The brain wants to hear things that are familiar, it wants comfort, it wants references. And what we’re looking for is exactly the opposite,” he said about writing Bankrupt! in a recent interview with Fader. “Exactly the opposite” is quite the stretch for a band as historically comforting to hear as Phoenix, no matter what shoes they’ve tried wearing. Even on their eclectic 2000 debut, United, when Mars first unveiled his talk-sing voice over arrangements that fell anywhere between dead-earnest disco and punk, you knew the guys. But on their last effort in 2009, Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix, they whittled those personalities down to their most focused collection of pop songs yet, earning themselves a huge breakthrough and validation from major festivals, the Grammy committee, Saturday Night Live, etc.

Opting out of another shot at those accolades, Phoenix leave Wolfgang on the podium and aim for their most curious collection with Bankrupt!. The two albums share mostly the same ingredients – same lineup, same instruments, same length, same co-producers in themselves and Philippe Zdar – but this time, they nuke the “pop” element at its core. Bankrupt! is by far the band’s most disruptive listen, repeatedly teasing a safe Wolfgang follow-up before pivoting on its own heels, sometimes headed towards more challenging ground, and sometimes finding themselves rather lost.

Consider “Oblique City”, the album’s other bookend and most blatant example of this contortion. It opens with a candy-coated blend of bouncing keys, Mars’ falsetto skips, and a sunshiny melody that some of the more hard-edged Phoenicians might find a little soft. And then a harsh key change barges in, and the whole thing turns into mud. And then it fades out with a minute of an acoustic guitar, otherwise completely absent on Bankrupt!, twinkling away like nothing just happened. Even if it’s exactly what they intended, it’s reasonable grounds for one-and-done listening.

Yet for every “oblique” moment on Bankrupt!, there’s a redeemer nearby to persuade “1901” loyalists to just hear them out. “Chloroform”, for one, presents an alternative route they could have spent a whole album pursuing if they wanted: one that employs a contrast between crystal-vivid fidelity and dirt-low bass synths to flavor R. Kelly-informed slow jams. But Bankrupt!’s true show-stopper arrives at “Bourgeois”. Much like “Choroform”, it cranks both tension and tempo down a few notches, clearing the way for Mars’ voice to attack its perfect hook with grace and gusto, as free as it’s ever sounded.

This isn’t the first time we’ve seen such a sharp deviation on a post-blowup album from an international synth-pop sweetheart in recent memory. A crude comparison can be made in the transition between Oracular Spectacular and Congratulations by MGMT, another group that’s displayed both a readiness and reluctance to head a new pseudo-class of modern indie rock ambassadors to dance music circles. Bankrupt! could end up the most anti-pop pop album of the year, which is exactly as confusing as the album sounds at times. But if the choice was between confusing or boring and safe, Phoenix made the right call.

Essential Tracks: “Entertainment”, “Chloroform”, and “Bourgeois”.

Feature artwork by Dmitri Jackson

COS_Phoenix feature

Purchase this artwork (via Society6): Print || Canvas || iPhone Case || Laptop Skin

9 comments

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Jeff Yates
April 25, 2013 at 9:14 am

The way each song flows (maybe jumps) through disparate movements reminds me of Of Montreal – as does the occasional bubble-gum pop ecstasy that delights the ears almost to fruition, but gets shot down every time with a looming, minor-key synth section. On first listen I skipped through quickly, searching for analogs of digital whippets like “Fences” and “1901”– a search for a quick high that ended in disappointment. But on my second or third run-through of the album, Bankrupt makes me think a more attentive listen is rewarded tenfold. No cheap thrills here – you gotta work for your nut. A useful analogy in books: if Wolfgang is your mass-market, best-selling thriller, then Bankrupt is your assigned summer reading that you’ll wish you’d actually read now that you’re older and feeling dumb when those books come up at cocktail parties. You need only skip to track two, “The Real Thing,” and wait for the beat to drop about a minute in to get your release to all that cacophonous tension. Phoenix still brings the giggles, but it’s a more heady buzz this time around.

Adam Marks
April 23, 2013 at 9:51 am

Between this review and the confession of distaste for Radiohead, I have to say that CoS dropped the ball this week. Weird, usually pretty spot on. For me at least.

Michael Roffman
April 23, 2013 at 9:59 am

The confession is a reflection on the writer’s behalf — not of the site’s. If you can’t see the difference, then I would suggest reading it again.

Adam Marks
April 23, 2013 at 10:05 am

I understand that the writer doesn’t reflect the thoughts and opinions of the entire CoS staff…That’s not what I said. But I am a reader….reading it on your site, reacting to it.

I’m all for writer – reader engagement, but you guys sure like to fire back.

jeffort23
April 22, 2013 at 11:30 am

When is a fruit not a fruit? When it’s fake marmalade. Sound, image and authenticity clash on Phoenix’s Bankrupt!

http://ludditestereo.com/2013/04/22/bankrupt-phoenix-album-review/

Steven Arroyo
April 22, 2013 at 11:11 am

Hmmm, not sure how you’re both reading a submission that “Entertainment”
or its bridge is “bad” or “good”. Was simply getting at how it sums up much of the Bankrupt! listening experience: difficult. That’s essential to me.

Alex Rogers
April 22, 2013 at 6:56 am

entertainment isn’t a part of this album is it? I feel like you’re jumping the gun a bit with this review… What justification do you have for these criticisms? Being critical is very different to just throwing insults… I actually felt as though the “climaxes” you were talking about weren’t really intended as climaxes, and the 50 notes they apparently hit were all rather good… Nicholas is right, why bother insulting entertainment so much then calling it an essential?

Nicholas Nissen
April 22, 2013 at 2:42 am

You take a whole paragraph to complain about why “Entertainment” isn’t that great of a song, and then end up putting it in the Essential Tracks selection anyway. You don’t even mention “The Real Thing” or “Trying to Be Cool”, the former belonging right next to “Chloroform” in style, and the latter easily being one of Phoenix’s best songs ever. Did you give this one play through and then write the review?

benbutton
April 25, 2013 at 6:43 pm

I personally think The Real Thing is the best track on the album. Partially agree it’s a difficult listen at times but there are no doubt great songs on it (3.5 stars is pretty accurate).