Is it unfair to fault a band for not consistently reinventing themselves? Probably. After all, if everyone is Radiohead, then no one is Radiohead, and change is not always a guarantee of progress and can even be devolution. Is it possible for a band to maintain relevance while building a career out of sticking to a time-tested formula? Not for Oasis, at least. In the case of British Sea Power, the band has taken the middle ground. On their debut, The Decline of British Sea Power, they found a template that worked for them, and have been refining it along the way ever since.
Critics have drawn overused, but nevertheless apt, parallels between U2 and British Sea Power, thanks to a shared penchant for grandiose anthems with arena-style choruses and crescendos. These comparisons are also unfair, because the two acts do not sound much alike and British Sea Powers sound includes atmospheric and post-punk numbers along with the soaring epics. When announcing Valhalla Dancehall, British Sea Power described lead single Living Is So Easy as having “electronic keyboards, some Louis Vuitton and clay pigeons and drawing influence from Serge Gainsbourg and Ralf and Florian-era Kraftwerk with a sprinkle of Stock, Aitken and Waterman.
Perhaps this description is a dig at both these comparisons and the sometimes ridiculous attempts by music journalists to describe a bands sound, or maybe its completely sincere. In any case, Living Is So Easy immediately stands out as one of the poppier and more electronic songs from British Sea Power. The breath of fresh air is short-lived, as Valhalla Dancehall covers mostly familiar territory. Songs such as We Are Sound and Observe the Skies represent the uptempo, hyper-literate side of British Sea Power, while the likes of Baby and Cleaning out the Rooms exemplify their recognizable, slow-burning swell.
Benefiting from lyrics topical to the plight of cut-protesting students in the UK, the stadium-stomping Whos in Control delivers an anthemic chorus with such an inspiring sense of urgency that one does not have to be invested in the politics in order to shout along. Thin Black Sail is a raucous post-punk rocker that could well have come from The Decline of British Sea Power, but its still an effective diversion punctuating Cleaning out the Rooms and the spellbindingly sprawling nine-minute Once More Now. These songs illustrate how the familiar and the engrossing need not be mutually exclusive.
British Sea Power has reach-for-the-stars ambitions and their sweeping anthems sometimes grab a hold of greatness.Valhalla Dancehall is more of the same from British Sea Power, which is not necessarily a bad thing, but the band has done most of it before in a more memorable fashion. Nevertheless, fans of British Sea Power will likely find their visit to Valhalla Dancehall an enjoyable one.