Exclusive Features
Anniversaries, Cover Stories, Editorials,
Interviews, Lists, and Comprehensive Rankings

Ranking: Every Album by The National from Worst to Best

on May 17, 2019, 12:28pm
view all

The National turn 20 this year. Take a moment to reflect on that. Of all the indie rock bands to emerge from New York City at the turn of the millennium, only a few have aged as gracefully as the Brooklyn-via-Cincinnati quintet. Think about it: The Strokes, Interpol, and Yeah Yeah Yeahs are nearly two decades removed from their instant-classic debuts, and you can count on one hand the number of truly great albums they’ve released thereafter. The National have a strong (and arguably winning) challenger in Vampire Weekend, and another in LCD Soundsystem, which raises the question of whether or not New York’s best indie rock bands are even rock bands.

(Read: Did Vampire Weekend Win the Indie Rock Age?)

If The National sound like a rock band, it’s almost entirely thanks to the brothers Dessner (Aaron and Bryce, both guitarists) and Devendorf (Scott on the bass, Bryan on the drums), because frontman Matt Berninger doesn’t sing about what other rock bands sing about. While Julian Casablancas, Paul Banks, and Karen O spun vivid tales of debauchery after dark, Berninger sings about more relatable matters — failing relationships, unfulfilling office jobs, and crippling hangovers. You’re friends with the characters that inhabit these songs, if you’re not already one of them.

(Buy: Tickets to Upcoming Nationals Shows)

If that makes The National “boring” — an epithet that’s been lobbed at the band since the beginning — it’s also the secret to their longevity. Listening to Is This It, Turn on the Bright Lights, and Fever to Tell, it’s practically an upset that the guys who made The National went on to produce some of the most rewarding, affecting music of the 2000s. To celebrate the band’s 20 years, as well as the release of their newest work, I Am Easy to Find, we’ve revisited and ranked The National’s eight albums. (That means we’re leaving off a few of their finest songs: “Exile Vilify”, the Cherry Tree EP’s “About Today”, and their cover of the Grateful Dead’s “Morning Dew”.) If you’ve yet to take an uninnocent, elegant fall into the band’s discography, we’ve got you covered.

-Jacob Nierenberg
Contributing Writer

__________________________________________________________

08. The National (2001)

The National - The National

Runtime: 43:51 (12 tracks)

“I Must Be Me, I’m in My Head” (Best Berninger-ism): “If I were a spy in the world inside your head/ Would I be your wife in a better life you led?” (“Bitters & Absolut”)

“Sorrow Waited, Sorrow Won” (Saddest Song): Although every song from The National is sorrowful to some degree, the narrative of cubicle misery in “Theory of the Crows” digs deepest into dismay. “Traded my daylight for a career,” Berninger sulks in his signature baritone. It features a heavy 6/8 beat that feels as inert and lethargic as the fluorescent-lit, windowless office that Berninger sings about. Like every other track on the band’s self-titled record, the instrumentation is unfiltered and sparse, but “Theory of the Crows” slowly strips itself away of all embellishment as it nears its end, striking a metaphor for withering away at a desktop.

“We’ll Run Like We’re Awesome” (Best Song): If there’s any song on The National that foreshadows what the band will soon become, opener “Beautiful Head” is incredibly prescient. Not only is this the introduction to their self-titled debut, but it was the introduction to The National in general. Most of The National’s 2001 record consists of alt-country and slide guitar, but “Beautiful Head” is the pure indie rock reminiscent of Alligator, The National’s breakthrough and still beloved LP.

“So Surprised You Want to Dance with Me Now” (Best Live Song): The National seldom play any tracks live from their first album, but “Cold Girl Fever” is a song that would make for a nice surprise amid the band’s more modern material. Similar to “Beautiful Head,” “Cold Girl Fever” was predictive in that it contains many songwriting elements The National are known for. It has Berninger’s crooning attitude and clever lyrics and even some synth experimentation seen on later albums such as Sleep Well Beast and I Am Easy to Find. Including a song like this on their upcoming tour would sonically make sense, and it’d be a reward for those following the band since their origins.

“I’ll Explain Everything to the Geeks” (General Analysis): The National’s self-titled debut, while not by any means a bad record, was more of an embryonic stage for the band than a definitive one. During this era, the Cincinnati quintet (then a quartet, Bryce Dessner wasn’t a member yet), was still determining its sound. The National is brimming with alt-country, an influence that’s nowhere to be seen on albums such as Boxer or Alligator. Though few fans have likely given this album a thorough listen, The National is an important beginning step in the band’s discography.

–Grant Sharples

__________________________________________________________

07. Sad Songs for Dirty Lovers (2003)

The National - Sad Songs for Dirty Lovers

Runtime: 44:54 (12 tracks)

“I Must Be Me, I’m in My Head”: “We look younger than we feel/ And older than we are” (“It Never Happened”)

“Sorrow Waited, Sorrow Won”: Sad Songs for Dirty Lovers is such a perfect title for a National album — it’s like Murder Ballads for Nick Cave or The Shape of Jazz to Come for Ornette Coleman. (It’s also a title that could apply to about half of Morrissey’s albums and any of Leonard Cohen’s.) The saddest song on Sad Songs, and arguably one of the five saddest songs this band has ever made, is “Cardinal Song”. There’s a muted, immersive quality to the instrumentation, almost as if it was recorded underwater, whereas Berninger’s vocals sound like they’re coming at you from the next bar stool over. “Never tell the one you want that you do,” he purrs. “Save it for the deathbed.” You can’t get much bleaker than that.

“We’ll Run Like We’re Awesome”: The jump in songwriting quality from The National to Sad Songs is immediate from the first few tunes, especially “Slipping Husband”. Berninger sings to a friend who more or less gave up his career to become a family man, and now he’s in danger of losing that very family. It has the makings of a tragedy, but it’s spiked by some of Berninger’s most brutally funny lyrics, including telling his friend: “You could have been a legend, but you became a father.” By the end of the song, even he doesn’t want to hear his buddy’s fantasies: “Dear, we better get a drink in you before you start to bore us.” It holds up pretty well musically, too, a punchy, chiming track that builds to a raucous, screamed climax in its final minute.

“So Surprised You Want to Dance with Me Now”: Much like The National, Sad Songs has effectively been retired from live performances. “Available”, “Cardinal Song”, and “Murder Me Rachael” appeared on setlists as recently as 2014, but the only cut off of Sad Songs you’re likely to hear today is “Lucky You”. It’s a breakup song, sure, but the tone isn’t one of bitterness so much as resignation; Berninger’s ex-lover is still going to have a hold on him long after she’s found someone else. “You own me/ There’s nothing you can do,” he sings, not that there’s anything he can do, either. It took the crowd about a minute to spot this one when The National played it at the Red Hat Amphitheater in Raleigh, NC, last May, but as soon as it registered, the only person in the room talking was Berninger.

“I’ll Explain Everything to the Geeks”: I’ll admit that I can’t remember the last time I listened to Sad Songs in full before taking on this piece. In revisiting it, I was pleasantly surprised: it’s hardly a definitive musical statement of purpose, but it’s better than your average early-aughts indie rock album. In its lesser moments, Sad Songs sounds like a more-refined version of what you heard on their debut, but its best songs feature sharper lyrics and some signs of musical experimentation. It’s a good album in its own right, but Sad Songs is most important in how it transformed the band who released The National into the band who would release Alligator.

–Jacob Nierenberg

__________________________________________________________

06. I Am Easy to Find (2019)

The National - I Am Easy to Find

Runtime: 63:35 (16 tracks)

“I Must Be Me, I’m in My Head”: “First Testament was really great/ The sequel was incredible/ Like the Godfathers or the first two Strokes/ Every document’s indelible” (“Not in Kansas”)

“Sorrow Waited, Sorrow Won”: The National’s new record, I Am Easy to Find, closes on a plaintive note with the piano ballad “Light Years”. As the Mike-Mills-directed short film that accompanies the album suggests, I Am Easy to Find revolves around concepts of life, death, and impermanence. It showcases a woman, portrayed by Alicia Vikander, experiencing both the joys and ills of life, and as her life comes to an end, “Light Years” plays straight into the credits. “The glory of it all was lost on me/ ‘Til I saw how hard it’d be to reach you,” Berninger broods. “And I would always be light years away from you.” The luscious strings and soft piano that bubble underneath Berninger’s vocals only augment the melancholic atmosphere.

“We’ll Run Like We’re Awesome”: When a song bleeds past the infamous five-minute mark, it can typically be condensed so that it doesn’t become monotonous. There are only two songs on The National’s eighth LP that exceed this length, but in both instances, it’s time well spent, particularly in the case of “So Far, So Fast”. It’s a slow build that never bursts into an expected release. It’s a track that takes its time, leading the listener to somewhere completely unknown, littered by sparse percussion, guitar harmonies, and angelic vocals from the Brooklyn Youth Chorus.

“So Surprised You Want to Dance with Me Now”: It’s no secret that The National have already played quite a few tracks from their latest album live, one of which is the incredibly percussive “Where Is Her Head”. They debuted it with indie singer-songwriter Phoebe Bridgers back in April, and it opens with simple, repeated chords, followed by auxiliary percussion and later Bryan Devendorf’s crackling snare and punchy bass drum. The lyrics are composed almost completely of questions (“Is she outside? Is she looking out? Is she standing up?”), which pair perfectly with Mike Mills’ equally ambiguous short film.

“I’ll Explain Everything to the Geeks”: I Am Easy to Find and the album that preceded it, Sleep Well Beast, almost beg to be compared to each other. The same synth experimentation and loop manipulation seen on Sleep Well Beast is found here. Even the exact haunting synth that opens “I’ll Still Destroy You” is heard on “So Far, So Fast” and “Quiet Light”. And it may be easy to make such comparisons, but I Am Easy to Find is an entirely new direction for The National. They’ve never had nearly as many collaborators before, including Sharon Van Etten, Gail Ann Dorsey, and Lisa Hannigan to name a few. It’s a record that also takes liberties with its length, but not to its detriment. Instead of being overzealous, it’s patient, and it asks listeners for this patience, too. Because of this, it may not have the immediate appeal of records such as High Violet or Boxer, but it’s all the more rewarding and adventurous for it.

–Grant Sharples

__________________________________________________________

05. Sleep Well Beast (2017)

the national sleep well beast

Runtime: 57:32 (12 tracks)

“I Must Be Me, I’m in My Head”: “Young mothers love me, even ghosts of/ Girlfriends call from Cleveland/ They will meet me anywhere” (“Day I Die”)

“Sorrow Waited, Sorrow Won”: Sleep Well Beast puts its saddest foot forward first with “Nobody Else Will Be There”. The song enters the picture slowly before snapping into focus, not that there’s much to focus on beyond a minimal piano riff and some clicks and whirs in the background. But that’s all it needs as Berninger pleads with the woman he loves to step outside the party they’re at for a second and talk to him about their fraying relationship. And when Berninger’s voice unexpectedly leaps into its upper register at the three-minute mark — “Hey baby, where were you back there/ When I needed your help?” — it never fails to break my heart.

“We’ll Run Like We’re Awesome”: During its recording, Berninger described Sleep Well Beast as “weird, math-y, electronic-y,” and for the most part, these experiments hit more than they miss. Of the hits, “I’ll Still Destroy You” is the most satisfying and haunting. “It’s so easy to set off the molecules and the caplets,” Berninger gravely intones over ghostly coos and skittering beats. He’s terrified — not just of substances that make him feel more level but less like himself, but of what his volatile psyche might be doing to his family. “I swear you got a little taller since I saw you,” Berninger lovingly sings to his daughter on the brink of the song’s violent conclusion, before delivering the song’s most crushing line: “I’ll still destroy you.” As bad as the fear of doing damage to your loved ones is, it pales in comparison to the realization that you’ve already passed it on.

“So Surprised You Want to Dance With Me Now”: On the whole, Sleep Well Beast is The National’s mess-around-with-electronics album, but it’s got some of their hardest-rocking material since the Alligator days. Case in point: “Day I Die,” which the band has played at nearly every show since the record dropped. If you don’t already believe Bryan Devendorf is among the best drummers in indie rock, you will within the first 30 seconds. Couple that with a chorus that begs to be shouted along to, and the screeching guitar that responds to it, and you’ve got The National’s most anthemic track in years.

“I’ll Explain Everything to the Geeks”: From a purely lyrical standpoint, Sleep Well Beast is top-tier National. The central narrative of the album is about saving a crumbling marriage, which gets really meta when you consider that Berninger’s wife, Carin Besser (a former fiction editor for The New Yorker), co-wrote the lyrics with him. (She’s had writing credits on previous songs, but never across a full album.) It’s musically where Sleep Well Beast falters. Some of the more experimental songs, such as “I’ll Still Destroy You” and “Guilty Party”, successfully marry electronic elements to The National’s signature brand of brooding, while others, such as “Walk It Back” and the title track, aren’t interesting enough to justify their length. Objectively, Sleep Well Beast is a good album, and for two thirds of its hour-long runtime, The National deliver the kind of emotionally resonant songwriting that has made them indie rock heavies for two decades. It’s just that for much of the other third, they don’t.

–Jacob Nierenberg

__________________________________________________________

04. Trouble Will Find Me (2013)

The National - Trouble Will Find Us

Runtime: 55:06 (13 Tracks)

“I Must Be Me, I’m in My Head”: “I have only two emotions/ Careful fear and dead devotion” (“Don’t Swallow the Cap”)

“Sorrow Waited, Sorrow Won”: Trouble Will Find Me is arguably the most somber record from The National, which is quite the feat considering this is a band whose albums revolve around sorrow. With that said, each track on the band’s sixth LP is its own descent into despair and despondency, but opener “I Should Live in Salt” sets the tone for the remainder of the album. The song centers on Matt Berninger’s complicated relationship with Tom Berninger, his younger brother. Tom’s documentary about the band, Mistaken for Strangers, has a scene that features The National working on this song, following the dysfunction and frustration that permeates throughout the film. “Don’t make me read your mind/ You should know me better than that,” Berninger laments. Brotherhood can be difficult, but “I Should Live in Salt” serves as both an apology and a declaration of love.

“We’ll Run Like We’re Awesome”: The best song from Trouble Will Find Me comes as the record nears its end, when the final notes of “Humiliation” ring out and fade away. “Pink Rabbits” starts with a memorable piano hook and swung drums before Berninger enters the mix with “I couldn’t find quiet/ I went out in the rain.” Throughout the band’s discography, stormy weather constantly surfaces as a metaphor for Berninger’s dejection. Roughly halfway through, he returns with some of the most indelible lyrics of his career: “You didn’t see me, I was falling apart/ I was a television version of a person with a broken heart.” He doesn’t have the luxury of doing menial tasks to ease the pain. On television, he’s never allowed this reprieve, forced to face his sadness directly with no distractions.

“So Surprised You Want to Dance with Me Now”: The National’s sixth record has some of the best live material in the band’s history, and with ballads like “Hard to Find” and “Slipped”, Trouble Will Find Me’s songs often make for a welcome break in between the band’s more well-known tracks. But the third single, “Graceless”, showcases the quintet with an unexpected energy and swiftness. In the outro, Berninger lets loose in the live version with almost feral screams, and Bryan Devendorf’s drums add a momentum unusual for the typically quiet, mid-tempo indie rockers.

“I’ll Explain Everything to the Geeks”: 2013 saw The National at their bleakest, and it also saw them release some of their best work with Trouble Will Find Me. Death and sadness are central themes here, and they’re also a springboard for the Dessner brothers’ magnificent compositions and Berninger’s heartfelt lyrics. Although his lyrics are often difficult to decipher and relish in secrecy, Trouble Will Find Me finds him at his most direct.

–Grant Sharples

__________________________________________________________

03. High Violet (2010)

The National - High Violet

Runtime: 47:40 (11 Tracks)

“I Must Be Me, I’m in My Head”: “You said it was night inside my heart, it was/ You said it should tear a kid apart, it does” (“Anyone’s Ghost”)

“Sorrow Waited, Sorrow Won”: A lot of words come to mind when I’m trying to describe the sound of High Violet — “nervous,” “opulent,” “jittery,” “claustrophobic” — but “sad” isn’t one of them. “Lemonworld”, on the other hand, is a song drenched in sadness. Despite the opening lyric, Berninger’s narrator doesn’t sound happy to be at whatever party he’s at; in fact, he doesn’t sound like he could be happy anywhere. Through guitars that rumble like storm clouds, Berninger quakes under the weight of his guilt and privilege — he’s as far away from the ongoing war as he is from his comfortable childhood — as he imagines the titular dreamland. A lemonworld sounds like heaven, but “Lemonworld” sounds like hell.

“We’ll Run Like We’re Awesome”: It’s quite possible that “Bloodbuzz Ohio” is the single greatest song The National have produced thus far. It’s certainly the quintessential National song, to the point where it almost feels like a checklist of everything a National song should be. Driving, thwacking drumbeat from Bryan Devendorf? Check. Lyrics that touch on disconnection, financial woes, and intoxication? Check. Cathartic swells of strings and fanfare? Check. Turn of phrase that’s so absurd it just might be profound? Yup: “I was carried to Ohio in a swarm of bees.” Hell, even the music video features Berninger moping in a bar. Like all highs, it doesn’t last, but for four and a half minutes, Berninger’s blood buzz sounds glorious.

“So Surprised You Want to Dance With Me Now”: We could be cute and say “Sorrow” — which The National infamously played over 100 times as part of an art installation by Ragnar Kjartansson — but we won’t. (They later sold a box set of the performances, fittingly titled A Lot of Sorrow, and I don’t know what’s more incredulous — that the 1,500-edition set sold out or that someone put the whole damn thing, all six hours of it, on YouTube.) Instead, this one goes to “Terrible Love”. The National often conclude shows with High Violet’s opener, and it’s not hard to hear why: its coda is perhaps the warmest and loudest moment on the album, and it sounds even warmer and louder from the stage. No sooner than Berninger screams, “It takes an ocean not to break!” at the climax do the Dessner brothers give him one, washing out the song in spectacular fashion with wave after wave of guitar distortion.

“I’ll Explain Everything to the Geeks”: Critics saddled High Violet’s two predecessors (and superiors — keep reading) with the term “grower,” but The National’s fifth album might be their easiest to love. (At the time, some reviewers went so far as to call it their best.) It’s their fullest- and grandest-sounding album, to the point where it’s practically impossible to imagine these songs without the horn and string sections. It’s also possibly their darkest, thanks to Berninger’s violent and surreal lyrics; at one point, he burns down a blackberry field “just to see what it kills” (“Little Faith”), then later threatens to eat his wife’s brains (“Conversation 16”). None of this kept High Violet from becoming the band’s most-acclaimed and best-selling album yet (it debuted at No. 3 on the US Billboard 200) and deservedly so.

–Jacob Nierenberg

__________________________________________________________

02. Alligator (2005)

The Boxer - Alligator

Runtime: 48:00 (13 tracks)

“I Must Be Me, I’m in My Head”: “Without warm water in my head/ All I see is black and white and red/ I feel mechanical and thin / Hear me play my violin again” (“Karen”)

“Sorrow Waited, Sorrow Won”: Alligator mirrors The National’s self-titled debut in the sense that Berninger mourns a happy life he’s traded for workplace success. This happens about halfway through the record on “Baby, We’ll Be Fine”. He opens with lyrics such as “All night I lay on my pillow and pray/ For my boss to stop me in the hallway/ Lay my head on his shoulder and say/ ‘Son, I’ve been hearing good things.’” Berninger sings about waking up each morning and facing himself in the mirror, trying to convince himself that he enjoys his life. His job has even obstructed his ability to have a healthy marriage (“You spill Jack and Coke in my collar/ I melt like a witch and scream”).

“We’ll Run Like We’re Awesome”: The National’s third LP undoubtedly contains some of the band’s best songwriting in their discography, and “Daughters of the Soho Riots” is a microcosm of that. It’s one of the quieter moments on Alligator, with piano and an acoustic guitar acting as a canvas for Berninger to sing about blending into a large crowd and being interminably lost. Bryan Devendorf’s percussion is muted and hushed, giving way for Berninger’s lyrics and Bryce Dessner’s gentle guitar melody.

“So Surprised You Want to Dance with Me Now”: Similar to The National’s other older material, like their self-titled debut and Sad Songs for Dirty Lovers, the band rarely plays any tracks live from Alligator. But the closing track, “Mr. November,” is consistently a part of their setlist and typically finds its way toward the end of the show. It’s one of the most vibrant and lively tracks The National have ever released, and it showcases this in the chorus when Berninger howls, “I won’t fuck us over, I’m Mr. November!” and Bryan Devendorf plays less of a groove and more of a looped drum fill. Aside from making for the best live song from Alligator, it’s a stellar way to close the record in general.

“I’ll Explain Everything to the Geeks”: Following two albums that were more searches for a distinguished sound than anything authoritative, Alligator breaks that trend by affirming who The National are and what they are known for. Berninger’s lyrics became more sharp and memorable, and Aaron Dessner’s instrumentation found a focus and an unequivocal splendor. This is the point in the Ohio band’s career where they announced themselves with unapologetic confidence, and although their music leans toward the shy and reticent, Alligator confirmed The National as an indie rock band worth anyone’s time.

–Grant Sharples

__________________________________________________________

01. Boxer (2007)

the national boxer Ranking: Every Album by The National from Worst to Best

Runtime: 43:07 (12 tracks)

“I Must Be Me, I’m in My Head”: “Turn out the light, say goodnight/ No thinking for a little while/ Let’s not try to figure out everything at once” (“Fake Empire”)

“Sorrow Waited, Sorrow Won”: Adulthood is a long, slow-motion process of losing people. Whether it be due to life’s uncertainties or death’s certainty, both family and friends will walk out of doors they won’t walk back through — sometimes swiftly and unexpectedly, sometimes gradually and knowingly but no less inevitably. “Green Gloves” is about trying to fight this process by remembering a loved one after they’re gone. There’s a sense of longing to the chorus (“Get inside their clothes with my green gloves/ Watch their videos in their chairs”), but the obsessive tension that fueled “Brainy” two songs earlier is absent; instead, “Green Gloves” glows with empathy. Even the song’s title evokes a surgeon, delicately trying to understand the innermost secrets of a body, hoping that it may be put it back together and made whole again.

“We’ll Run Like We’re Awesome”: Boxer’s opening one-two punch features two of the most beloved songs in The National canon, and the following four are every bit as strong. Closing out that six-song streak is “Slow Show”, Boxer’s beating heart. It starts in a familiar place for Berninger — drunk at a party he’d very much like to leave — and builds gorgeously from there, with woodwinds, strings, and even an accordion rising and falling like the tide. It’s at 2:31 that the song unfolds into its devastating outro, with Berninger resurrecting a chorus from the band’s debut: “You know I dreamed about you/ For 29 years before I saw you.” When we first heard these words on “29 Years”, they came off as a drunken plea. Here, they sound like a long-lost love letter — a promise rediscovered and reaffirmed.

“So Surprised You Want to Dance With Me Now”: “Fake Empire” is The National’s signature song, so it’s no surprise that the audience loses its collective mind every time that familiar piano polyrhythm rings out from the stage. The band has louder, sadder, better songs, but “Fake Empire” truly captures the live National experience. It’s in the way the crowd sings along to the refrain; it’s in the way the band members still visibly get a kick out of playing this song, despite the fact that it’s been on the setlist for virtually every one of their shows for the last 12 years. And to be honest, it’ll probably stay there until the band calls it quits.

“I’ll Explain Everything to the Geeks”: Boxer is the definitive National album. It’s the one where both Berninger’s voice and his lyrics got noticeably deeper. It’s the one where Bryan Devendorf leveled up and became one of the tightest and most propulsive drummers in indie rock. It’s the one where the Dessner brothers really figured out how to work with an orchestra, which has been an essential part of the band’s sound ever since. All of this to say: Boxer is where The National became the band they are today. A year after Boxer, the band was opening for R.E.M.’s final tour and had given Barack Obama permission to feature “Fake Empire” in a campaign video. A band that crawled out of the underground to define an era and a young leader with a vision of a bright and hopeful future; a little over decade later, it’s getting harder and harder to find those, if they even exist anymore. But The National is still here, watching over us as we try to make our way through the unmagnificent lives of adults.

–Jacob Nierenberg

view all